Ok, so my Fix really came yesterday, but I was traveling for work and didn't get home until late, so I didn't do much with it until this morning when the boys headed off to school. Elliott was pretty excited about my October Fix!
I was really excited about my stylists note that there were NO tank tops in this order and it was "only fall clothes and warm colors". Awesome, because that's what I asked for! I am trying to give really good feedback each month so that next month I get a more "fitting" box of goodies. This month, I feel like an effort was made....but still missed the mark a bit.
So, let's get to it!
The FIRST item I pulled out was this Brixton Ivy Lawley Cable Knit Open Cardigan for $68.
Initial thoughts - it's super soft and heavy and cozy, but it's grey....bland, boring, grey....how many months have I been saying I want COLOR!?!?!?
The SECOND item I pulled was this Parkhurst Jeffrey Waffle Knit Colorblock Sweater for $84.
Initial thoughts - I pinned this EXACT sweater to my pin board! I love when they send me something I really wanted! It's super cute and a weird (but fun) material. I can't really explain it, but I knew out of the box I was probably keeping this one....even though it's the most expensive thing in this Fix. Go figure.
The THIRD item I pulled was this 41Hawthorn Colibri Solit Tab Sleeve Blouse for $48.
Initial thoughts - Ooooh - 41Hawthorn has been my favorite brand....but....AWESOME...I pretty much DESPISE Hunter Green. Plus, the top is pretty boring aside from the tab sleeves. Probably going back....
The FOURTH item I pulled was this 19 Cooper Rosetta V-Neck Top for $64.
Initial thoughts - Good color, but I hate the pattern, the material feels cheep, and it looks way too short for me. Most likely going back...
The FIFTH and final item in this fix is a pair of Liverpool Denise Bootcut Jeans for $78.
Initial thoughts - I don't own black jeans....for good reason. Something about the smell of black denim that just gets to me. No matter how many times you wash them, they still smell. Anyone agree?
PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER
The FIRST outfit I tried was the Parkhurst Jeffrey Waffle Knit Colorblock Sweater and the Liverpool Denise Bootcut Jeans.
Thoughts - I really wanted to like this sweater...but it just was NOT flattering. With my hips, if it's not fitted a little, it just looks boxy...and this is exactly what's happening here. The jeans....sooooo comfy. Perfect fit, but still black and smelly.
The SECOND outfit I tried was the Parkhurst Jeffrey Waffle Knit Colorblock Sweater and the black jeans.
Thoughts - I'll probably never wear this with black jeans....because these black jeans are probably going back, but I LOVE the sweater. It's warm and comfy and while it's not fitted, it still has a bit of shape that works with my figure.
The THIRD outfit I tried was the 19 Cooper Rosetta V-Neck Top and black jeans.
Thoughts - just as I thought. The cut of this shirt is too boxy and short. It does nothing to flatter my figure. Plus, I really just hate the print and the material.
The FOURTH and final outfit I tried on was the 41 Hawthorn Colibri Solid Tab Sleeve Blouse and black jeans.
Thoughts - I don't know why, but last night when I was thinking about this shirt, I kept going back to pairing it with a yellow necklace. I was hoping it would work without making me look like a Packers fan. So, With the necklace, I really kind of loved this shirt. SURPRISE! Right? It was comfy, flowy (but just enough of a shape), and really flattering. Plus, I actually REALLY liked it with the black jeans! BIGGER SURPRISE! I have yellow shoes that would complete this outfit....too much?
THE VERDICT
1) Brixton Ivy Lawley Cable Knit Open Cardigan - going back. I wanted to love it, but I just didn't.
2) Parkhurst Jeffrey Waffle Knit Colorblock Sweater - KEEPING
3) 19 Cooper Rosetta V-Neck Top - going back. I hate almost everything about this shirt.
4) 41 Hawthorn Colibri Solid Tab Sleeve Blouse - keeping. I'm surprised, but I really like it...hunter green and all. Not to say I wouldn't like it BETTER in another color, but I think this is a good step out of my "norm" for me, and that's kind of the point, right?
5) Liverpool Denise Bootcut Jean - I'm really on the fence here. If it weren't for how they looked with the green shirt, they'd for sure be going back. Not sure I can justify a $78 pair of jeans that I don't love, though. Plus, this shirt will look just as good with the several (I mean...tons) of dark denim jeans I have. So, still mulling it over, but pretty sure these are going back.
So, an interesting fix and a mix of good, bad, and surprises! Looking forward to more fall and winter Fixes in coming months!
Interested in subscribing to Stitch Fix so you can join the fun? Click the link below to schedule your fix!